Home › Guides › Exchanges with offerors
TendersWhat are exchanges with offerors, and what stays confidential?
Source last checked: 17 November 2026
After proposals arrive, FAR 15.306 allows clarifications, communications and discussions, and only discussions let you revise your proposal. Throughout, the Government must not reveal another offeror’s price without permission, its technical solution, or the names of past performance references. Your own price may be called too high or too low.
The exchanges an agency can hold once proposals are in
After proposals arrive, FAR Part 15 recognises exchanges of different weight: clarifications, communications, and negotiations, which in a competitive acquisition are called discussions. The label is not cosmetic. It decides who the agency may talk to, what it may raise, and above all whether you are allowed to change your proposal afterwards.
| Exchange | When it happens | Can you revise the proposal? |
|---|---|---|
| Clarifications | When award without discussions is contemplated | No. Limited exchanges only, for things such as past performance relevance or minor or clerical errors |
| Communications | After receipt of proposals, leading to establishment of the competitive range | No. They "shall not provide an opportunity for the offeror to revise its proposal" |
| Discussions | After the competitive range is established | Yes. They are undertaken with the intent of allowing the offeror to revise its proposal |
Source: FAR 15.306, Exchanges with offerors after receipt of proposals (acquisition.gov).
Clarifications: narrow, and only when discussions are not planned
Clarifications are the lightest exchange, and they exist only in the world where the agency intends to award without discussions. FAR 15.306(a)(1) calls them "limited exchanges, between the Government and offerors, that may occur when award without discussions is contemplated."
What may be clarified is narrow: FAR 15.306(a)(2) gives the relevance of your past performance information, adverse past performance information you have not previously had an opportunity to respond to, and minor or clerical errors. A missing cost volume is not a clerical error, and clarifications are not a route to supply it.
The solicitation is what makes this path available. Under FAR 15.306(a)(3) award may be made without discussions if the solicitation says the Government intends to evaluate proposals and make award that way; if the agency then decides discussions are necessary after all, the rationale "shall be documented in the contract file."
Source: FAR 15.306(a), Clarifications and award without discussions (acquisition.gov).
Communications: held with a short list, and not with everyone
Communications sit before the competitive range exists, and they are not offered to the whole field. FAR 15.306(b)(1) limits them to offerors whose past performance information is the determining factor keeping them out of the range, and to those whose exclusion from, or inclusion in, the range is uncertain. If your proposal is clearly in or clearly out on the merits, you should not expect one.
Their purpose is to let the agency understand what you wrote, not to let you improve it. Under FAR 15.306(b)(2) they may enhance Government understanding of proposals, allow reasonable interpretation of the proposal, or facilitate the evaluation, and they "shall not be used to cure proposal deficiencies or material omissions, materially alter the technical or cost elements of the proposal, and/or otherwise revise the proposal." They may still be considered in rating proposals for the purpose of establishing the competitive range, so a weak answer here can cost you a place.
FAR 15.306(b)(3) lists what they may address: ambiguities in the proposal or other concerns, such as perceived deficiencies, weaknesses, errors, omissions, or mistakes, and information relating to relevant past performance. Adverse past performance information you have not had a chance to comment on must be put to you.
Source: FAR 15.306(b), Communications with offerors before establishment of the competitive range (acquisition.gov).
Discussions: bargaining, and what the contracting officer must raise
Discussions are the only exchange that invites a revised proposal, and they begin after the competitive range is set. FAR 15.306(d) defines negotiations as exchanges "undertaken with the intent of allowing the offeror to revise its proposal", and says they may include bargaining: persuasion, alteration of assumptions and positions, give-and-take, applied to price, schedule, technical requirements, type of contract, or other terms.
There is a floor on what you must be told. Under FAR 15.306(d)(3) the contracting officer must indicate to, or discuss with, each offeror still being considered for award its deficiencies, significant weaknesses, and adverse past performance information it has not yet had an opportunity to respond to. The same paragraph sets the ceiling just as plainly: the contracting officer "is not required to discuss every area where the proposal could be improved", and "the scope and extent of discussions are a matter of contracting officer judgment." A discussion round that stays silent on a minor weakness is not a defect in the process.
Discussions are also tailored. FAR 15.306(d)(1) requires them to be tailored to each offeror's proposal and conducted by the contracting officer with each offeror within the range, so what your competitor was asked tells you nothing about what you will be asked.
Being in the range is not a guarantee of staying. FAR 15.306(d)(5) allows an offeror that is no longer among the most highly rated to be eliminated "whether or not all material aspects of the proposal have been discussed, or whether or not the offeror has been afforded an opportunity to submit a proposal revision."
At the end, FAR 15.307(b) gives each offeror still in the competitive range an opportunity to submit a final proposal revision, with a common cut-off date for receipt, and the request must advise you that the revision is to be in writing and that the Government intends to award without obtaining further revisions. Once you are out of the range, FAR 15.307(a) closes the door: no further revisions to that proposal "shall be accepted or considered."
Sources: FAR 15.306(d) and FAR 15.307, Proposal revisions (acquisition.gov).
What stays confidential: the limits on exchanges
This is the part most bidders actually want, and it is written as a prohibition on Government conduct rather than as a promise to you. FAR 15.306(e) reads:
(e) Limits on exchanges. Government personnel involved in the acquisition shall not engage in conduct that—
(1) Favors one offeror over another;
(2) Reveals an offeror's technical solution, including—
(i) Unique technology;
(ii) Innovative and unique uses of commercial products or commercial services; or
(iii) Any information that would compromise an offeror's intellectual property to another offeror;
(3) Reveals an offeror's price without that offeror's permission. However, the contracting officer may inform an offeror that its price is considered by the Government to be too high, or too low, and reveal the results of the analysis supporting that conclusion. It is also permissible, at the Government's discretion, to indicate to all offerors the cost or price that the Government's price analysis, market research, and other reviews have identified as reasonable (41 U.S.C. 2102 and 2107). When using reverse auction procedures (see subpart 17.8), it is also permissible to reveal to all offerors the offered price(s), without revealing any offeror's identity;
(4) Reveals the names of individuals providing reference information about an offeror's past performance; or
(5) Knowingly furnishes source selection information in violation of 3.104 and 41 U.S.C.2102 and 2107).
FAR 15.306(e), acquisition.gov, FAC 2026-01
Read the price item closely, because it is narrower than it first looks. Your price is protected from disclosure, but your own price is fair game in your own discussion: the contracting officer may tell you it is too high or too low and show you the analysis behind that view. The agency may also tell the whole field what its price analysis and market research found to be reasonable. Reverse auctions under subpart 17.8 go further still, with offered prices revealed to all offerors but identities withheld.
Note too what the technical item protects: unique technology, innovative and unique uses of commercial products or services, and anything that would compromise your intellectual property. A commonplace approach described in commonplace terms is not made confidential by appearing in your proposal.
What you are told when you are excluded or lose
Exclusion comes with a written notice, and the notice has to say why. Under FAR 15.503(a)(1) the contracting officer notifies offerors promptly in writing when their proposals are excluded from the competitive range or otherwise eliminated, and the notice "shall state the basis for the determination and that a proposal revision will not be considered."
After award, FAR 15.503(b)(1) requires written notification within 3 days of the date of contract award to each offeror whose proposal was in the competitive range but was not selected. It includes the name and address of each offeror receiving an award, the items, quantities and any stated unit prices of each award, and in general terms the reasons your proposal was not accepted. The limit on all of it is explicit:
In no event shall an offeror's cost breakdown, profit, overhead rates, trade secrets, manufacturing processes and techniques, or other confidential business information be disclosed to any other offeror.
FAR 15.503(b)(1)(v), acquisition.gov
Debriefings follow the same pattern: a real account of your own evaluation, and a wall around everyone else's. A preaward debriefing under FAR 15.505(e) includes the agency's evaluation of significant elements in your proposal, a summary of the rationale for eliminating you, and reasonable responses to relevant questions about whether the stated source selection procedures were followed. FAR 15.505(f) then withholds the number of offerors, the identity of other offerors, the content and ranking and evaluation of other offerors, and anything prohibited by FAR 15.506(e).
A postaward debriefing is wider, and includes the overall evaluated cost or price and technical rating of the successful offeror alongside yours, the overall ranking of all offerors where a ranking was developed, and a summary of the rationale for award, under FAR 15.506(d). It still "shall not include point-by-point comparisons of the debriefed offeror's proposal with those of other offerors", and FAR 15.506(e) keeps back trade secrets, privileged or confidential manufacturing processes and techniques, privileged or confidential commercial and financial information including cost breakdowns, profit and indirect cost rates, and the names of individuals who gave past performance references.
Timing is on you. FAR 15.505(a)(1) requires a written request within 3 days after receipt of the notice of exclusion; FAR 15.506(a)(1) requires a written request received within 3 days after the date you received notification of contract award. Miss it and, under FAR 15.505(a)(3) and 15.506(a)(3), you need not be given a debriefing at all. You are entitled to no more than one debriefing for each proposal.
Sources: FAR 15.503 (acquisition.gov), FAR 15.505 (acquisition.gov), FAR 15.506 (acquisition.gov).
Before proposals arrive, the rules point the other way
Early exchanges are encouraged rather than restricted, which catches some bidders out when they expect the same confidentiality in a presolicitation meeting that they get in a discussion round. FAR 15.201(c) encourages agencies to promote early exchanges and lists techniques for it, among them one-on-one meetings with potential offerors, draft RFPs, RFIs, and presolicitation or preproposal conferences.
Once the solicitation is out, FAR 15.201(f) makes the contracting officer the focal point of any exchange, and requires that specific information about the acquisition that is necessary for preparing proposals and disclosed to one or more potential offerors be made available to the public as soon as practicable, "in order to avoid creating an unfair competitive advantage." The same paragraph then protects you in the one place it matters: information provided to a potential offeror in response to its request "must not be disclosed if doing so would reveal the potential offeror's confidential business strategy", and is protected under FAR 3.104 or subpart 24.2.
Proposals themselves are protected from the moment they land. FAR 15.207(b) requires that proposals "shall be safeguarded from unauthorized disclosure throughout the source selection process", with RFI responses safeguarded adequately as well.
Sources: FAR 15.201 (acquisition.gov), FAR 15.207 (acquisition.gov).
A worked example: what can and cannot be said in one discussion round
Take a competitive acquisition for a software maintenance service. Your proposal is in the competitive range. Two other firms are in it as well. The contracting officer opens a discussion round with you.
Things the contracting officer may do in that room, with the paragraph that permits each:
- Tell you that your staffing plan has a deficiency and a significant weakness, and name them, because FAR 15.306(d)(3) requires it.
- Tell you that your price is considered too high, and show you the analysis supporting that conclusion, under the express carve-out in FAR 15.306(e)(3).
- Tell you what the agency's own price analysis and market research identified as a reasonable price, at the Government's discretion, under the same paragraph.
- Put adverse past performance information to you that you have not yet had a chance to answer, again under FAR 15.306(d)(3).
- Suggest that your proposal would be more competitive if you removed features that exceed a stated mandatory minimum in ways not integral to the design, and lowered your price, under FAR 15.306(d)(4).
Things that the limits in FAR 15.306(e) put out of bounds in the same room:
- Telling you a competitor's price, unless that competitor gave permission.
- Describing a competitor's technical solution, its unique technology, or an unusual use it has made of a commercial product.
- Naming the people who gave past performance references about any offeror, including you.
- Telling you where you rank, or how many firms are in the range. Ranking is a postaward debriefing item under FAR 15.506(d)(3), and the number of offerors is withheld even in a preaward debriefing under FAR 15.505(f)(1).
And one asymmetry worth planning for: the contracting officer is under no obligation to mention everything that is wrong with your proposal. Under FAR 15.306(d)(3) the floor is deficiencies, significant weaknesses and unanswered adverse past performance. A moderate weakness can go unmentioned, survive into your final proposal revision, and still count against you in the award decision. Silence on a point is not approval of it.
What this guide does not cover
FAR Part 15 governs contracting by negotiation, and nothing else. FAR 15.002 splits it into sole source and competitive acquisitions, and the notification, debriefing and protest rules discussed above sit in subpart 15.5, whose scope FAR 15.502 states directly: that subpart applies to competitive proposals as described in FAR 6.102(b) and to a combination of competitive procedures under FAR 6.102(c). For sole source acquisitions and those described in FAR 6.102(d)(1) and (2), the procedures in FAR 15.504, 15.506, 15.507, 15.508 and 15.509 "should be followed" with reasonable modification, which is a weaker instruction than the one that governs a competitive buy.
That leaves real gaps, and they are where bidders most often cite the wrong rule:
- Sealed bidding. FAR 15.000 treats a contract awarded using other than sealed bidding procedures as a negotiated contract, so a sealed bid acquisition runs under FAR Part 14 rather than Part 15, and the exchange vocabulary on this page does not transfer to it.
- Simplified acquisition. Buys made under FAR Part 13 have their own, lighter procedures. FAR 15.503(b)(2) does reach across: on request, the contracting officer furnishes unsuccessful offerors in simplified acquisition solicitations the information described in FAR 15.503(b)(1). What does not come with it is the competitive range and discussion machinery of FAR 15.306.
- Protests. Nothing here is a protest procedure. FAR 15.507(a) sends protests against award in negotiated acquisitions to FAR Part 33, and a delayed debriefing can affect the timeliness of a protest filed after it, under FAR 15.505(a)(2).
- Agency supplements. Agencies may add their own supplements to these rules, and this page does not reproduce them.
- Cost and pricing data. What the agency may require you to submit, and when certification is triggered, is a separate body of rules in subpart 15.4 rather than part of the exchange rules.
Sources: FAR 15.000, FAR 15.002, FAR 15.502 and FAR 15.507, Part 15 Contracting by Negotiation (acquisition.gov).
Questions bidders ask about exchanges with offerors
Can I change my proposal during clarifications?
No. Clarifications under FAR 15.306(a) are limited exchanges available when award without discussions is contemplated, and they cover things such as the relevance of your past performance information or minor or clerical errors. Only discussions, which happen after the competitive range is established, are undertaken with the intent of allowing you to revise your proposal.
Does the agency have to tell me every weakness in my proposal?
No. FAR 15.306(d)(3) requires the contracting officer to raise deficiencies, significant weaknesses, and adverse past performance information you have not yet had an opportunity to respond to. The same paragraph says the contracting officer is not required to discuss every area where the proposal could be improved, and that the scope and extent of discussions are a matter of contracting officer judgment.
Can a contracting officer tell me my price is too high?
Yes. FAR 15.306(e)(3) prohibits revealing an offeror's price without permission, but expressly allows the contracting officer to tell you that the Government considers your price too high, or too low, and to reveal the results of the analysis supporting that conclusion. The agency may also indicate to all offerors the cost or price its price analysis and market research identified as reasonable.
Can I be dropped from the competitive range after discussions have started?
Yes. Under FAR 15.306(d)(5), an offeror originally in the competitive range that is no longer considered among the most highly rated may be eliminated whether or not all material aspects of its proposal have been discussed, and whether or not it was given a chance to submit a proposal revision. Written notice of that decision goes out under FAR 15.503.
Will a debriefing show me the winning proposal?
No. A postaward debriefing under FAR 15.506(d) gives you the successful offeror's overall evaluated cost or price and technical rating, the overall ranking of all offerors where one was developed, and a summary of the rationale for award. FAR 15.506(e) bars point-by-point comparisons with other proposals and withholds trade secrets, confidential manufacturing processes, confidential commercial and financial information such as cost breakdowns and profit, and the names of past performance references.
How long do I have to ask for a debriefing?
Your written request has to reach the agency within 3 days: after receipt of the notice of exclusion for a preaward debriefing under FAR 15.505(a)(1), or after the date you received notification of contract award for a postaward debriefing under FAR 15.506(a)(1). If the request is not timely, you need not be given a debriefing, and you are entitled to no more than one debriefing for each proposal.
Do these exchange rules apply to a simplified acquisition buy?
Not as such. The competitive range, communications and discussion rules of FAR 15.306 belong to contracting by negotiation. A buy made under FAR Part 13 uses simplified procedures, although FAR 15.503(b)(2) does require the contracting officer, on request, to furnish unsuccessful offerors in those solicitations the postaward information described in FAR 15.503(b)(1).
Related guides
- What can you ask for in a federal debriefing, and when?
- When must you submit certified cost or pricing data?
- When can a US agency use simplified acquisition instead of full competition?
See the negotiated procurements your firm can bid on
Scalebiz extracts eligibility conditions from call notices, checks the core ones — country, legal form, registration, turnover and team size — against your profile, and flags each opportunity as core conditions met or needing a manual check. Fourteen days, no card.
Start the 14-day trialSource. This guide describes FAR Part 15 as codified today. On 18 September 2026 the FAR Council published a proposed rule rewriting Parts 8, 12, 13, 15, 38, 44 and 51 under Executive Order 14275 (91 FR 59406, FAR Case 2026-003). It is a proposal, not the text in force. Agencies may also be operating under class deviations that differ from the codified text quoted here. All quotations are from FAR Part 15, Contracting by Negotiation, edition FAC 2026-01, effective 13 March 2026, published at acquisition.gov. The copy in the Scalebiz corpus was retrieved on 1 September 2026; the live text of FAR 15.000, 15.201, 15.207, 15.306, 15.307, 15.503, 15.505 and 15.506 was read again and the cited paragraphs confirmed on 17 November 2026, which is the date shown above. Scalebiz is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice.
Written by Robert Grabarević, founder of Scalebiz. He built the radar as a tool for himself, so that he would not have to re-read the same funding rules for every application. Every guide on this site cites the regulation by section or page, so each claim can be checked against the source. About Scalebiz · Robert on LinkedIn.